Intro: Does the introduction provide a strong rational for why the study is need

Intro:
Does the introduction provide a strong rational for why the study is needed? What is it?
Are research questions and hypothesis clearly articulated? What are they?
Method:
What method is used?
Is the method described so that replication is possible without further information?
Are subject recruitment and selection methods described?
Measures:
For all measures did the authors provide evidence of reliability and validity either by summarising data or by referring the reader to an available source that provides the information?
Do the measures match the research questions and hypothesis being asked?
Discussion:
What are the significant results?
Do the authors have a humility section that mentions the limitations of the research including methodological problem?
Do the authors poit out aspects of subject selection, procedures and dependent variables that limit the generalisability of the findings?